Ancient Wisdom or Modern Insight?
Arguments for God's Existence in Paul's Mars Hill Sermon
This article is a revised re-release of an original piece first published on December 13, 2023. As part of an ongoing effort to strengthen and clarify past content, we are reviewing, updating, and re-uploading selected articles to ensure accuracy, improved readability, and alignment with our current editorial standards.
Ancient Wisdom or Modern Insight?
Arguments for God’s Existence in Paul’s Mars Hill Sermon
Introduction
The existence of God is not an abstract philosophical inquiry. It is the foundation of every sermon, every prayer, and every moral obligation. When Paul stood on Mars Hill in Athens, he addressed the most learned men of his day and made a case for the living God. Paul’s approach did not rest on novelty or speculation. He set forth the truth revealed by God and anchored it in observable reality.
The arguments presented in Acts 17 are as relevant now as they were in the first century. They have been studied, refined, and categorized by generations of theologians and philosophers, but their core remains unchanged. These arguments derive from the revelation of God, not from human invention. Every Christian should know them, teach them, and defend them.
1. God as Creator: The Cosmological Argument
“God that made the world and all things therein, seeing he is Lord of heaven and earth, dwelleth not in temples made with hands” (Acts 17:24).
Paul began with the fact of creation. The universe does not account for itself. Every effect has a cause, and the chain of causes cannot regress infinitely. The existence of the world points directly to a necessary cause. Paul identified that cause as God. He made the world and all that is in it. He is not bound by temples or confined by human hands.
The Cosmological Argument emerges from this reality. If anything exists, there must be a sufficient explanation. The world bears the marks of design, origin, and purpose, all of which lead to the Creator. Paul dismissed every attempt to credit creation to local deities, chance, or myth. The Christian position is grounded in the fact that God stands as the uncaused Cause behind all things.
2. God as the Necessary Being: The Ontological Argument
“Neither is worshipped with men’s hands, as though he needed any thing, seeing he giveth to all life, and breath, and all things” (Acts 17:25).
Paul described God as the source of all life, independent of human needs or offerings. The Ontological Argument affirms that God, by definition, is the greatest conceivable being. He is not improved by worship, nor diminished by neglect. All life, breath, and existence depend on Him, not the other way around.
Idolatry reduces deity to the level of the created. Paul confronted that error directly. God does not need, lack, or require. He possesses all things inherently. Any conception of God that falls short of this is insufficient. Christians must continue to uphold the truth that God’s nature is self-sufficient and absolute.
3. God as Designer and Ruler: The Teleological Argument
“And hath made of one blood all nations of men for to dwell on all the face of the earth, and hath determined the times before appointed, and the bounds of their habitation” (Acts 17:26).
Paul pointed to the order and structure present in creation and human history. Nations exist, boundaries are set, and times are appointed—not by chance, but by divine purpose. The Teleological Argument draws attention to the observable order in the universe and in history. Such regularity does not emerge from chaos.
Paul’s statement reveals God’s intentional design. He governs the affairs of men and the progress of nations. The world is not the product of accident. Christians must insist that order, structure, and purpose in nature all testify to a sovereign Designer.
4. The Universal Search for God: The Religious Argument
“That they should seek the Lord, if haply they might feel after him, and find him, though he be not far from every one of us” (Acts 17:27).
Paul recognized the universal impulse to seek meaning beyond the material. All cultures develop religious forms. All people search for transcendence. Paul traced this impulse to the Creator Himself. God made man with the capacity and desire to seek Him. The Religious Argument draws its strength from this universal phenomenon.
Paul’s words affirm that God is near. He is accessible, not remote. The urge to worship, to search for higher purpose, reflects God’s design in humanity. Christians should never treat faith as an accident of culture. It is an answer to a longing placed in every human heart by the One who made it.
5. God as the Ground of Morality: The Moral Argument
“For in him we live, and move, and have our being; as certain also of your own poets have said, For we are also his offspring” (Acts 17:28).
Paul established that every facet of life is grounded in God. All existence depends on Him. Even the pagan poets recognized a connection between humanity and the divine. The Moral Argument finds its basis in this relationship. Every culture demonstrates a sense of right and wrong. Objective morality points to a moral Lawgiver.
Morality cannot be fully explained by evolution, social contract, or personal preference. It reflects the will and nature of God. Paul’s use of the poets demonstrated that, even in the absence of revelation, humanity retains some awareness of moral accountability to a higher source. Christians must defend the truth that God alone grounds the standards of right and wrong.
6. Beauty, Creativity, and the Divine: The Aesthetic Argument
“Forasmuch then as we are the offspring of God, we ought not to think that the Godhead is like unto gold, or silver, or stone, graven by art and man’s device” (Acts 17:29).
Paul addressed the Athenians’ artistic representations of deity. While human creativity reflects something of the divine image, it cannot capture or contain God. The Aesthetic Argument notes that the human pursuit of beauty, meaning, and creativity points beyond mere survival. Art, music, and beauty belong uniquely to humanity. This pursuit testifies to a Creator who endowed His offspring with an appreciation for the transcendent.
Paul did not minimize artistic achievement. He drew a clear line between Creator and creation. Christians must recognize that beauty, like morality and reason, reflects the nature of God but can never define or limit Him.
Conclusion
Paul’s defense on Mars Hill was not limited by the categories of later philosophy. He spoke truth as God revealed it and as reason confirms it. The Cosmological, Ontological, Teleological, Religious, Moral, and Aesthetic arguments remain enduring because they are grounded in Scripture and reality.
God stands as the Maker of all things.
God possesses all sufficiency.
God orders creation and history with purpose.
God placed within humanity the drive to seek Him.
God grounds all moral obligation.
God is the source of all beauty and art.
Each point stands as a challenge to idolatry and a summons to faith. The world remains in need of these truths. Christians are called to present them without apology, with clarity and conviction, so that all who seek may find the living God.